[MUD-Dev] [BIZ] Advertising sprawl (yahoo)
Caliban Tiresias Darklock
caliban at darklock.com
Wed Apr 18 00:12:03 New Zealand Standard Time 2001
On Tue, 17 Apr 2001 22:30:06 +0000 (GMT), Matt Mihaly
<the_logos at achaea.com> wrote:
> Web banner advertising crashed and burned because the expectations
> were too high. It's not like it doesn't work. It just doesn't
> justify the prices people were previously paying.
It might, if it worked properly.
Sometimes I'll go to a site and see a banner I would REALLY like to
click on -- in a few minutes, once I get done with what I'm doing.
Unfortunately, when I have to go to another page to finish what I'm
doing, I lose the banner. Sometimes it's still there when I hit the
back button, but more often it's not. It's not always possible to
"copy shortcut" and stick it in a text editor for later, either,
dynamically generated script kept in a source file on the server. The
rotation and tracking of banners effectively turns "show me your
stuff" into "can't be bothered". It is only on VERY rare occasions
that I will sit at some page and reload repeatedly until the banner I
want to follow comes back up. I think I've done that twice, and on
both occasions it turned out to be a waste of time anyway, so I
wouldn't hold my breath waiting for it to happen again.
If I could just go to a page on the site that showed me all the ad
banners, I'd go there and look for the one I was interested in. Then
I'd see all the other banners, too -- and I'm already in a "click on
the banner" mood, so they'd be in a really good place. But I
can't. Nobody does that. And that's not really the answer, either:
what I *really* want is some way I can say "yes, I'm interested, but
not right now" and then I could get a reminder to check it out later
on. Wouldn't that be nice? Couldn't some nice person start a service
that would keep track of all the banners you clicked and just send you
a friendly reminder once a week? I'd *read* that. And if it carried a
few extra ads, that's just fine.
And if you put your ad banner in a dinky little window that's in my
way, I close it before I even bother to look at what's on it. Rule #1
of advertising: don't annoy me! Annoyed people don't buy things!
In short, web banners don't work because the people who use them are
incompetent. Not a single one of them has sat down and said "how do I
want web banners to work when I'm browsing web sites?" -- they've said
"how do I want web banners to work when I'm looking at web banners?"
instead, but unfortunately nobody does that. Since when have you ever
gone out looking for ads on the net?
MUD-Dev mailing list
MUD-Dev at kanga.nu
More information about the MUD-Dev